Studies / Niagara-on-the-Lake wineries
Where does AI send people wine tasting in Niagara-on-the-Lake?
We asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Google the questions visitors ask about wine tasting in Niagara-on-the-Lake, 2,304 times, and recorded every winery they named.
The short answer
Five of Niagara-on-the-Lake’s 40 wineries get more than 40% of the mentions. And about 1 in 7 answers sends people to a winery that has closed, usually one still listed on an out-of-date web page the AI had read.
2,304 asks · 40 wineries · 6 platforms · November 13–15, 2026
What we found
Five things we found
01
Five wineries get more than 40% of the mentions.
Asked about Niagara-on-the-Lake, the AIs mentioned 38 of its 40 wineries. Five of them got more than 40% of the mentions: Peller Estates, Two Sisters, Ravine, Inniskillin and Trius. Peller Estates and Two Sisters made every platform’s top five. Ask about plain “Niagara”, and they get about half.
Mentions of the ten most-mentioned wineries (the top five in green)
Mentions of each winery in the 768 chat answers to the “Niagara-on-the-Lake” questions. The top five got 2,013 of the 4,784 mentions (42%); the other 30 wineries, not shown, shared 1,715. For “Niagara”, the top five got 1,939 of 3,703 (52%). November 13–15, 2026.
02
Two companies own 1 in 8 of the wineries but get about 1 in 3 of the mentions.
Arterra (Inniskillin, Jackson-Triggs) and the Peller group (Peller Estates, Trius, Wayne Gretzky Estates) own 1 in 8 of the wineries, but got about 1 in 3 of all the mentions. The AIs do follow the question, though: asked for small, family-run wineries, the two companies got only about 1 in 20.
The two companies’ share
Share of the wineries1 in 8
Share of all mentions1 in 3
Small, family-run questions1 in 20
Four AI chat platforms. The two companies own 5 of the 40 wineries. All mentions, both wordings together: 2,744 of 8,487 (32%). Small, family-run, “Niagara-on-the-Lake” wording: 68 of 1,461 (5%). November 13–15, 2026.
03
About 1 in 7 answers names a winery that has closed.
About 1 in 7 chat answers named a winery that has closed. The ones named most were Small Talk Vineyards, which closed in 2022; Frogpond Farm, which closed its winery this year; and The Ice House, which Google lists as permanently closed. How often it happened depends heavily on the platform: Claude did it in about 1 in 4 answers, ChatGPT almost never.
Answers that named a closed winery, by platform
Google AI Overview1 in 100
Answers to the “Niagara-on-the-Lake” questions that named a closed winery: Claude 52 of 192, Perplexity 37 of 192, Gemini 31 of 192, ChatGPT 2 of 192, Google’s AI Overview 1 of 100 (it counts only the 100 searches where it appeared). Across both wordings: 221 of 1,536 chat answers. November 13–15, 2026.
04
When an AI reads an old page, it often repeats it as if it were current.
Nearly every answer that named a closed winery had read a web page that still lists it, and all but one named the winery as a place to go, with no warning that it had closed. The biggest source is a MapQuest article on small Niagara wineries. As of November 18, 2026, it still lists Small Talk and Frogpond, and calls Bella Terra by its old name, Pondview.
Even asked directly whether The Ice House is open, Gemini and Perplexity said yes, 10 times out of 10. ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overview got it right.
How often the AI named Small Talk, which closed in 2022
Had read a page that still lists it1 in 2
Answers naming Small Talk: 130 of 268 that had read a page still listing it, 2 of 1,502 that hadn’t. All five AI platforms. Answers naming any closed winery that had read a page still listing it: 213 of 225. The MapQuest article was cited in 123 answers, including all 73 that used the name Pondview. Pages read on November 18, 2026. The direct question about The Ice House comes from our pilot on November 11, 2026: a smaller test of 10 asks per platform (8 for Google's AI Overview).
05
One word changes the answer.
Ask about “Niagara”, and about 6 in 10 chat answers named wineries outside Niagara-on-the-Lake, in places like Beamsville and Jordan. Say “Niagara-on-the-Lake”, and fewer than 1 in 10 did.
Answers that named a winery outside Niagara-on-the-Lake
Asked about “Niagara”6 in 10
“Niagara-on-the-Lake”1 in 11
Chat answers naming at least one winery outside Niagara-on-the-Lake: 454 of 768 (59%) for “Niagara”, 68 of 768 (9%) for “Niagara-on-the-Lake”. Four AI chat platforms, November 13–15, 2026.
A note on our numbers
These are what the AIs said on November 13–15, 2026, and AI answers change. Each question was asked 24 times per platform. That’s lighter than the standard we use for paid studies, so the headline shares are accurate to within about 4 to 8 points either way, and single-platform figures are a direction, not a precise number. A winery counts once per answer, however many times the answer names it. A closed winery counts whenever an answer names it (one of the 221 answers named it only to say it had closed), but not when it appears only as a former name of another winery. We read the cited web pages on November 18, 2026, not when the AIs read them, so finding 04 shows a strong link, not proof that a given page caused a given answer. Google’s AI Overview counts only when Google showed one.
How we measure →